Infectious DiseasesDr. Neha Rastogi PandaHIV and Tuberculosis

Senior Consultant, Infectious Diseases, Fortis Memorial Research Institute, Gurgaon

Part 8 of 9 in Tuberculosis & HIV - An Insight

When HIV Therapy Appears to Fail: Telling Adherence Problems From Real Failure

September 6, 2026

The cricketer from the tuberculosis co-infection case returns as the natural illustration of what treatment failure actually means, and what it doesn't. His CD4 count had fallen by two-thirds from its baseline and he had a new opportunistic infection, both signs that could point toward a failing regimen. Whether he genuinely needed a new regimen, or simply needed his adherence fixed, was the actual clinical question.

Three Kinds of Failure, Not One

Treatment failure is assessed on three separate axes. Clinical failure means a new infection or malignancy has developed on therapy. Immunological failure means the CD4 count has either dropped by 50 percent from its peak or has failed to rise meaningfully over one to two years on treatment. Virological failure, the most decisive of the three, means the viral load has not fallen below a significant threshold despite six months of therapy under national guidelines, or three months under WHO guidelines. A patient can show one of these signs without the others, and the distinction changes what happens next.

Why Resistance Testing Is the Exception, Not the Rule

Genotypic resistance testing is the ideal way to confirm true virological failure, but it is not available in most treatment settings. In its absence, the practical approach is to treat rising viral load, falling CD4 count and a genuine new clinical symptom together as sufficient evidence of failure, and to switch the patient's regimen on that basis rather than wait for a test that may never become available.

What a Second-Line Switch Actually Looks Like

A second-line regimen typically drops the integrase inhibitor and substitutes a ritonavir-boosted protease inhibitor, such as atazanavir or darunavir, for it. For the cricketer, that switch was never triggered: anti-tubercular therapy was started, his existing antiretroviral regimen was continued, and after three months of restored adherence his viral load had come down on repeat testing. His case wasn't a genuine treatment failure at all; it was a poor-adherence episode that resolved once the underlying cause, missed doses during travel, was addressed directly.

This guide is based on a live Jivo Masterclass: Dr. Neha Rastogi Panda taught doctors across Africa on March 30, 2025.

FROM THE LIVE Q&A

DR

Dr. Rabio

At what stage can we diagnose opportunistic infections, and how do we diagnose them?

NR

Dr. Neha Rastogi Panda

Opportunistic infections can be diagnosed at any stage; the WHO staging system, grade one through four, is built around exactly this, using the infection profile and CD4 level together. Oral thrush, for instance, usually appears at stage two, while reactive generalised lymphadenopathy sits at stage one. Sometimes the opportunistic infection is itself the first clue to an undiagnosed HIV infection, tuberculosis being the clearest example: finding it usually puts the patient at WHO stage three, and a very low viral load and CD4 count below 200 to 250 lets you further risk-stratify from there. Diagnosis runs on three legs: the clinical symptoms and signs, which organ is involved, and targeted sampling, such as testing sputum by GeneXpert for suspected pulmonary tuberculosis, or testing CSF, or serum cryptococcal antigen when CSF isn't accessible, for cryptococcal meningitis.

See all 4 questions from this masterclass →

Book a Consultation with Dr. Neha Rastogi Panda

Book on WhatsApp

Or message us on WhatsApp: +91 98182 98669

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the early signs of HIV?

The early signs, known as acute HIV syndrome, look like a flu. Most patients who are symptomatic present with intermittent fever for two to three months, fatigue or weakness, weight loss, loss of appetite, cough, cold, sore throat, more frequent minor illnesses than usual, and loose motions or diarrhoea. This symptom complex over the first month or two is what we call acute HIV syndrome.

Why don't we use the urine LAM test and stool test for all patients?

The urine lipoarabinomannan (LAM) test is reserved for tuberculosis diagnosis, and it has only been validated for patients with a CD4 count below 100. Below that threshold, a high tuberculosis bacterial burden allows the antigen to wash out into the urine; above it, the test loses sensitivity and specificity, so extrapolating it to every patient isn't supported. On stool testing for other opportunistic infections, a high viral load before treatment changes the normal gut flora, so a stool sample will often show excess normal flora and candida, which makes interpreting it for treatment decisions difficult specifically in HIV patients.

Are there any antiretrovirals that can have prolonged action for up to three or six months?

Yes. Cabotegravir, a longer-acting integrase inhibitor, combined with rilpivirine from the non-nucleoside reverse transcriptase inhibitor family, was studied in the TANGO trial and showed viral suppression sustained for close to three months from a single dose. Their half-life runs to about 24 to 26 weeks, so the combination is given as one intramuscular or subcutaneous injection every three months for patients who are already stable on oral therapy, as maintenance rather than as a starting regimen.

At what stage can we diagnose opportunistic infections, and how do we diagnose them?

Opportunistic infections can be diagnosed at any stage; the WHO staging system, grade one through four, is built around exactly this, using the infection profile and CD4 level together. Oral thrush, for instance, usually appears at stage two, while reactive generalised lymphadenopathy sits at stage one. Sometimes the opportunistic infection is itself the first clue to an undiagnosed HIV infection, tuberculosis being the clearest example: finding it usually puts the patient at WHO stage three, and a very low viral load and CD4 count below 200 to 250 lets you further risk-stratify from there. Diagnosis runs on three legs: the clinical symptoms and signs, which organ is involved, and targeted sampling, such as testing sputum by GeneXpert for suspected pulmonary tuberculosis, or testing CSF, or serum cryptococcal antigen when CSF isn't accessible, for cryptococcal meningitis.

Need Expert Medical Guidance?

Connect with leading specialists through the Jivo Healthcare network for personalized advice.

Get Expert Opinion