Chief - Laparoscopic Gynae & Robotic Surgery, Artemis Hospitals, Gurgaon, India
Part 5 of 13 in Role of Robotics in Benign Gynaecology
Myomectomy or Hysterectomy for Fibroids? How the Decision Is Made
August 6, 2026
The choice between myomectomy, which removes fibroids while keeping the uterus, and hysterectomy, which removes the uterus entirely, mainly depends on a woman's age and whether she still wants to have children.
When myomectomy is the right choice
For younger women who want to preserve their fertility, myomectomy, removing the fibroids while keeping the uterus intact, is generally the goal. Robotic surgery is particularly suited to this approach because of the strong, precise uterine reconstruction it allows, which is important for a uterus that may later need to support a pregnancy.
When hysterectomy may be recommended instead
For a perimenopausal woman around 48 years old who has completed her family and has multiple fibroids, Dr. Deepika Aggarwal explains that hysterectomy can be a reasonable choice. Very small fibroids, sometimes only the size of a peanut, cannot always be removed during myomectomy, and fibroids larger than around 1 to 2 cm can recur and regrow over time, which is a key reason some women choose to have the uterus removed rather than preserved.
A decision made together with the patient
Dr. Deepika Aggarwal describes talking patients through the pros and cons of myomectomy versus hysterectomy so they can make an informed choice based on their own priorities. Whichever option is chosen, robotic surgery offers the same advantages of precision, reduced blood loss and faster recovery for both myomectomy and hysterectomy procedures.
← Multiple Fibroids in African Women: Why Robotic Surgery Is Often the Better Option | Series index
This article is based on a Jivo Masterclass session conducted by Dr. Deepika Aggarwal, Chief, Laparoscopic Gynaecology and Robotic Surgery, Artemis Hospitals, Gurgaon, India. The article has been summarised with the assistance of an AI tool from the original masterclass recording. Watch the full Masterclass recording
This guide is based on a live Jivo Masterclass — Dr. Deepika Aggarwal taught doctors across Africa on January 11, 2026.
FROM THE LIVE Q&A
Prof. Daniel Okitondu, Kinshasa, DRC
What is the failure rate in robotic surgery?
Dr. Deepika Aggarwal
It depends what's meant by 'failure rate' — conversion to open surgery, complications, or the surgery not being viable at all. On not being viable: if you're an expert in robotic surgery, you should be able to make that decision pre-operatively through proper planning — getting an MRI or CT done if the ultrasound report isn't satisfactory. On complications: the risk of injury is less than 1% with robotic surgery — for bowel and vessel injury specifically the risk is less than 0.5%, and bladder injury is similarly low, compared with 1 to 2% with laparoscopic surgery.
Book a Consultation with Dr. Deepika Aggarwal
Book on WhatsAppOr message us on WhatsApp: +91 98182 98669
Frequently Asked Questions
What are your plans to expand training so more gynaecologists in developing countries like Ethiopia can become expert in robotic or laparoscopic surgery?▼
Artemis has been very proactive with all sorts of expansion, and is very much into the international world — we're there to support it. With the new digital world, things like today's Zoom session can happen, and I'll be very happy to be part of any travel needed, taking time out every couple of months to be with the doctors and patients there. I'm a very proactive person when it comes to teaching and training, because the skills we've acquired are good to spread around so more people can gain the expertise.
What is the cost implication of robotic surgery compared to laparoscopic or open surgery?▼
Robotic surgery is a little more expensive than laparoscopic surgery — depending on the type of surgery, somewhere around $1,000 to $1,200 extra than any conventional laparoscopic surgery.
With robotic surgery, is there no indication for hysterectomy in women with fibroids?▼
It depends on the age of the patient and her fertility desire. If it's a perimenopausal woman around 48 who has completed her family and has multiple fibroids, it's her choice whether she wants just the fibroids removed or the uterus removed too — sometimes women have very tiny peanut-sized fibroids we cannot take out at the time, and those can recur and regrow. So in many such women it's often better to think about getting the uterus removed rather than saving it. These are the kinds of discussions I'd have with the patient, taking them through the pros and cons of either, and then they can make a call.
Proficiency for complex robotic cases like endometrial cancer may be reached in fewer than 10 cases, compared to 40 for standard laparoscopy — what is your comment on this? And have you had to convert to open surgery?▼
People who train in robotic surgery are mostly already laparoscopic surgeons who've done many laparoscopic surgeries — very few robotic surgeons are 'de novo,' never having done laparoscopic surgery. If you've driven a manual car and now you're going to an automatic, proficiency comes sooner — you just need to learn to drive the robot. On conversion: I had one case in the last three to four years where I had to open a patient up, purely because during robotic surgery the patient's head is at a 30-degree angle, quite low down, and there was a lung compromise issue — the patient wasn't able to maintain oxygen saturation. We tried undocking the robot and raising her head, waited ten minutes and restarted, but her saturation kept dropping, so we had to open her up. That's the only case I can recall in three years, out of several hundred surgeries — patient selection is the most important thing.
How many robotic surgeries have you done in your career, and what was the success rate including post-operative recovery?▼
With God's grace, none of my patients have ended up in the ICU or anything like that — they've all recovered beautifully. I've done more than 400 to 500 robotic surgeries so far, and I cannot recall any complications in terms of injury to the bladder, bowel, or ureter — essentially a 100% success rate at the post-operative stage.
How do doctors decide between myomectomy and hysterectomy for fibroids?▼
The choice mainly depends on a woman's age and whether she still wants to have children. Myomectomy preserves the uterus for women who want future fertility, while hysterectomy may be recommended for women who have completed their family.
Why might a perimenopausal woman with multiple fibroids be advised to consider hysterectomy?▼
For a perimenopausal woman around 48 years old who has completed her family, hysterectomy can be a reasonable choice because very small fibroids cannot always be removed during myomectomy and can recur or regrow over time.
Does robotic surgery offer the same benefits for both myomectomy and hysterectomy?▼
Yes. Whichever option is chosen, robotic surgery offers the same advantages of precision, reduced blood loss and faster recovery for both myomectomy and hysterectomy procedures.
Why is myomectomy preferred for younger women who want children?▼
Myomectomy keeps the uterus intact, which is important for women planning a future pregnancy, and robotic surgery is particularly suited to this approach because of the strong, precise uterine reconstruction it allows.
In This Series: Role of Robotics in Benign Gynaecology
- 1.Role of Robotics in Benign Gynaecology
- 2.Open, Laparoscopic or Robotic Surgery: How Doctors Choose
- 3.Cost of Robotic Surgery in India Compared with Laparoscopic Surgery
- 4.Multiple Fibroids in African Women: Why Robotic Surgery Is Often the Better Option
- 5.Myomectomy or Hysterectomy for Fibroids? How the Decision Is Made
- 6.Robotic Hysterectomy: When It Is Used and What Recovery Looks Like
- 7.Robotic Myomectomy: Removing Fibroids While Preserving Fertility
- 8.Robotic Surgery Complication Rates: How Safe Is It?
- 9.Robotic Surgery in Gynaecological Cancer: Beyond Benign Conditions
- 10.Robotic vs Laparoscopic Surgery in Benign Gynaecology: What Is the Difference?
- 11.The Learning Curve for Robotic Surgery: How Fast Do Surgeons Become Proficient?
- 12.What Is Robotic Surgery? How the Robotic System Works in Gynaecology
- 13.Who Benefits Most from Robotic Gynaecological Surgery?