Consultant, Medical Oncology, Fortis Flt. Lt. Rajan Dhall Hospital, Vasant Kunj, New Delhi
Part 9 of 13 in From Detection to Recovery: Navigating the Future of Cancer Care
Breast Cancer: Subtypes, Diagnosis and Newer Targeted Treatments
September 6, 2026
Breast cancer is not one disease but at least three, and the distinction matters more for treatment than almost any other factor, as Dr. Nithin S.G. explained using two of his own patients' cases.
The Three Subtypes
Breast cancer is classified as hormone receptor positive, HER2 positive, or triple negative, based on IHC testing done on the biopsy sample itself, not on mammography, which is used only for initial evaluation. Triple negative breast cancer, where all three markers come back negative, is more aggressive and harder to treat once it reaches stage four. The diagnostic procedure, biopsy first, subtype testing on the biopsy sample, is the same regardless of which subtype is ultimately found.
Diagnosis: Mammography, Ultrasound and MRI
Mammography, a form of X-ray, can miss a tumour hidden within fattier breast tissue, which is more common in women under 30 to 35; in this age group ultrasound or MRI is preferred. After around 35 to 40, once fibrous tissue outweighs fat, mammography becomes more reliable and is offered first, since it is simpler and less costly than MRI. Core needle biopsy, not excisional biopsy, is the standard for confirming a suspicious finding, and excisional biopsy is reserved for small, likely benign lumps such as a fibroadenoma.
Two Cases That Show How Far Treatment Has Come
A 62-year-old woman presented with a breast mass that had eroded into her ribs and spread extensively to her axillary lymph nodes, too advanced for surgery. Biopsy confirmed hormone receptor positive metastatic disease, and she was started on two oral tablets, a CDK4/6 inhibitor combined with hormone therapy, rather than chemotherapy. Within six months, her chest wall lesion had shrunk out of view on CT and her enlarged axillary nodes had disappeared on repeat PET scan; four years later she remains on the same two tablets, with no surgery and no chemotherapy. A second patient, 45 years old, had ignored a small breast lump until she developed a sudden severe headache, vomiting and one-sided weakness. An MRI showed metastases in her cerebellum and brain stem, and biopsy confirmed HER2 positive breast cancer. Started on a monoclonal antibody drug conjugate called T-DXd as first-line therapy, her brain metastases had completely disappeared on a repeat scan, and she remains well roughly a year and a half later without surgery or chemotherapy.
← Immunotherapy: Retraining the Immune System to Fight Cancer | Series index | Targeted Therapy for Advanced Cancer Patients with Poor Performance Status →
This article is based on a Jivo Masterclass session conducted by Dr. Nithin S.G., Consultant, Medical Oncology, Fortis Flt. Lt. Rajan Dhall Hospital, Vasant Kunj, New Delhi. The article has been summarised with the assistance of an AI tool from the original masterclass recording. Watch the full Masterclass recording
This guide is based on a live Jivo Masterclass: Dr. Nithin S.G. taught doctors across Africa on May 11, 2025.
FROM THE LIVE Q&A
Doctor on the call (name unclear from transcript)
What is the difference between FNAC, core biopsy and excisional biopsy?
Dr. Nithin S.G.
FNAC (fine needle aspiration cytology) involves inserting a needle into a tumour or fluid-filled cyst and aspirating fluid along with a few detached cells for slide evaluation under a microscope; sensitivity is low since so few cells come through, and a pathologist can typically only confirm abnormal cells are present, not the exact cancer subtype needed for hormone receptor and HER2 testing. Core biopsy uses a biopsy gun that removes a cylindrical piece of tissue roughly a centimetre long, providing enough tissue for full histopathological and genetic workup, which is why core biopsy, not FNAC, is preferred whenever cancer is suspected.
Frequently Asked Questions
How is breast cancer diagnosed based on its hormone receptor status?▼
Breast cancer is broadly split into three types: hormone receptor positive, HER2 positive, and triple negative. The diagnostic procedure itself does not change based on subtype: a biopsy is still required, with mammography used only for initial evaluation. IHC testing on the biopsy sample determines ER, PR and HER2 status; if all three come back negative, the cancer is classed as triple negative, a more aggressive subtype that is harder to treat once it reaches stage four.
How does mammography compare to MRI for diagnosing breast cancer?▼
Neither is simply better in every case. MRI is the more definitive test to rule out cancer, but mammography, a form of X-ray, can miss a tumour hidden in fattier breast tissue, which is common in women under 30 to 35. In younger women, ultrasound or MRI is preferred; mammography becomes more effective after around 35 to 40, once fibrous tissue outweighs fat. MRI is more accurate but costlier and more involved for the patient, which is why mammography is offered first, with a PET-CT or a CT of the chest, abdomen and pelvis used for staging.
How effective is immunotherapy compared to other cancer medications?▼
Immunotherapy is highly effective and carries far fewer side effects than standard chemotherapy. In cancers with a large initial tumour burden, such as lung cancer, it is usually combined with chemotherapy at first, since immunotherapy alone takes time to bring a heavy disease burden under control. Once the disease responds, treatment continues on immunotherapy alone to maintain that response.
What specific investigation should be used to diagnose testicular cancer?▼
Any scrotal swelling should first be evaluated with ultrasound, which will show a testicular mass or enlargement, but there is no test that gives a confirmed diagnosis before surgery, that only comes after radical orchiectomy. Of 100 patients presenting with a testicular swelling, roughly 80 to 90 percent will have cancer and about 10 percent tuberculosis, so for the large majority a biopsy is avoided, since it risks spreading the cancer, in favour of going directly to orchiectomy. Tumour markers such as AFP and beta-hCG, elevated in seminoma and yolk-sac tumours, can support the ultrasound finding, but the standard recommendation regardless of marker levels is orchiectomy rather than biopsy.
How specific is PSA for prostate cancer, given a case where PSA was over 100 but the biopsy showed only BPH?▼
PSA is not specific for prostate cancer at all, no tumour marker is specific for any single cancer. An elevated PSA in a patient with a prostatic mass could reflect BPH or cancer, and can rise even after a digital rectal exam or ejaculation. Very high values, such as over 100, are more suggestive of cancer, so if PSA is extremely elevated yet the biopsy shows only BPH, the biopsy may simply have missed the cancerous core, which does happen. In such suspicious cases, a gallium-68 PSMA PET scan, highly specific for prostate cancer, can help confirm or rule out malignancy before treating for BPH alone.
What are the three subtypes of breast cancer?▼
Hormone receptor positive, HER2 positive, and triple negative, determined by IHC testing on the biopsy sample rather than by mammography.
Is mammography reliable for diagnosing breast cancer in younger women?▼
Not as reliable. Mammography can miss a tumour in the fattier breast tissue common in women under 30 to 35, so ultrasound or MRI is preferred in that age group.
What happened to a metastatic HER2 positive breast cancer patient with brain metastases?▼
Started on a monoclonal antibody drug conjugate as first-line therapy, her brain metastases had completely disappeared on a repeat scan, and she remained well roughly a year and a half later without surgery or chemotherapy.
In This Series: From Detection to Recovery: Navigating the Future of Cancer Care
- 1.From Detection to Recovery
- 2.When to Suspect Cancer: A Symptom Checklist by Cancer Type
- 3.From Suspicion to Diagnosis: Blood Tests and Imaging Explained
- 4.Why Biopsy Beats FNAC in Cancer Diagnosis
- 5.Tumour Markers: What They Can and Cannot Tell You
- 6.Cancer Staging and Why It Decides the Treatment Plan
- 7.Precision Oncology: How Genetic Testing Is Changing Cancer Treatment
- 8.Immunotherapy: Retraining the Immune System to Fight Cancer
- 9.Breast Cancer: Subtypes, Diagnosis and Newer Targeted Treatments
- 10.Targeted Therapy for Advanced Cancer Patients with Poor Performance Status
- 11.Testicular Cancer, Prostate Cancer and PSA: Working Up Common Urologic Presentations
- 12.Liquid Biopsy: A Newer, Less Invasive Way to Detect and Monitor Cancer
- 13.Uterine Fibroids Are Not Cancer: Why Targeted Therapy Doesn't Apply