Mechanical vs Tissue Heart Valve: How Doctors and Patients Choose

The patient should be referred for further evaluation at the appropriate time — not too early, but also not too late, because if it is too late the patient develops more comorbidities and the outcome may not be as good. For valve disease specifically, there are definite guidelines for mitral and aortic valve disease on when a patient should be referred for cardiac surgery; whether it can be done locally depends on whether it looks like a straightforward repair or replacement, or a more challenging one. The two important criteria are the patient's clinical symptoms — which functional class (1, 2, 3, or 4) — and the echo findings, which show the severity of stenosis or regurgitation, LV function, and pulmonary artery pressures. Together these decide whether the patient should be referred for surgical treatment, locally or elsewhere.

Cost primarily depends on two things: which valve is used — mechanical valves are significantly less expensive than tissue valves, and among tissue valves, third-generation valves cost more than second-generation ones — and the patient's clinical course, since a straightforward surgery without a long hospital stay or comorbidities costs less. The average cost generally starts from $9,000 and goes up to $15,000–$16,000.

Cardiac tumours in children are well known, though this exact pathology is not very common. The echo gives us an idea, but I would suggest also doing an MRI and a CT to further delineate it. I would like the details of this patient sent to our institute so we can forward it to our paediatric cardiac surgeon, since paediatric cardiac surgery is a separate subspecialty from the adult cardiac surgery I practise, and we do have a dedicated paediatric cardiac surgical team. This child needs very close follow-up and further investigation.

Tetralogy of Fallot is one of the commonest surgical procedures, and the outcome depends on the exact anatomy delineated by a proper paediatric echo, but six years is not a very late stage — in India a lot of patients are operated on at this age or even older. The outcome of tetralogy repair even at 6 years is excellent, so this patient certainly needs surgical correction.

Myocardial bridging is not uncommon and is often seen on angiography. If it is asymptomatic, nothing needs to be done. If it is symptomatic, we normally do a stress thallium test — if positive, we recommend surgery; if negative, which is most of the time, only medical treatment is needed. If it is only myocardial bridging with no stenosis involved in other arteries (the circumflex or right coronary artery are normal), nothing needs to be done, but if the stress test is positive, surgery is recommended.

Guidelines from the American College of Cardiology and American Heart Association, the European Society of Cardiology and European Association for Cardio-Thoracic Surgery, and the Indian Association of Cardiovascular and Thoracic Surgery all state that valve choice should be based on the desire of the informed patient, provided there is no contraindication to anticoagulants and the therapy can be managed appropriately.

Mechanical valves are generally preferred for younger patients in their 50s and 60s because they last longer and anticoagulation is easier to manage earlier in life. Tissue valves are generally preferred for patients over 60 to 65 because they degenerate more slowly in older patients and the risk of anticoagulation complications is higher in older age.

Women who want to become pregnant are advised to receive a tissue valve regardless of age, because the anticoagulants required with a mechanical valve carry risks to both mother and foetus.