Senior Urologist & Uro-Oncologist, Apollo Hospital Gurugram
Part 5 of 10 in Diagnosis and Management of Prostate Cancer
When to Biopsy: Balancing Missed Cancer Against Overtreatment
July 7, 2024
Prostate biopsy carries real risk, bleeding and infection among them, so the goal is never to biopsy everyone with a raised PSA. The real objective is finding clinically significant cancer: disease that is aggressive and likely to harm the patient, while avoiding unnecessary biopsy and treatment for clinically insignificant, indolent cancer that would never affect the patient's survival even if missed.
Balancing two risks at once
Because PSA can be elevated for many reasons, many patients undergo over-investigation and over-treatment that was never actually needed. The discipline required is striking a balance: never missing an aggressive cancer, while not overtreating everyone who doesn't actually have one.
When surgery isn't the right call at all
For patients who are very old, very sick, or who do not want further major treatment, biopsy may not be the right plan at all. In these cases, the honest conversation is about the risks and benefits of not investigating further and letting the patient be, rather than pursuing biopsy and treatment by default.
This article is based on a Jivo Masterclass session conducted by Dr. Nitin Shrivastava, Consultant, Urology and Uro-Oncology, Artemis Hospital, Gurgaon (his affiliation at the time of this session). The article has been summarised with the assistance of an AI tool from the original masterclass recording. Watch the full Masterclass recording
Looking for a urology consultation or a second opinion? Get in touch with the Jivo team
This guide is based on a live Jivo Masterclass: Dr.Nitin Shrivastava taught doctors across Africa on July 7, 2024.
FROM THE LIVE Q&A
Moderator
What is the best method of managing BPH?
Dr.Nitin Shrivastava
First make sure BPH is not causing damage to the kidneys. For mild symptoms, only lifestyle management is needed. For bothersome symptoms, a single alpha blocker is used. There is no one universal method; if it's damaging the kidneys, surgery is needed.
Book a Consultation with Dr.Nitin Shrivastava
Book on WhatsAppOr message us on WhatsApp: +91 98182 98669
Frequently Asked Questions
Apart from PSA, what other hormones should be monitored in case of prostate cancer?▼
None. PSA is the only one.
What are the factors contributing to prostate cancer, and what are the staging parameters?▼
The most important contributing factor is genetics and family history. Researchers point to some role of obesity and possibly a non-vegetarian diet, but these risk factors are not firmly established.
What is a neobladder? What is an ileal conduit? How will treatment affect my quality of life?▼
Neobladder and ileal conduit are treatments for bladder cancer, not prostate cancer. A neobladder is an artificial bladder made from the patient's intestine, stitched together so the patient continues to pass urine through their natural passage. An ileal conduit instead diverts urine to exit through a different passage into a bag. On quality of life: what matters most in the long run is that the cancer comes out of the body completely; patients adjust well to either option over time.
Is there a limitation on the number of times TURP can be done on the same patient?▼
About 10 out of 100 patients will require another TURP within the following 10 years. There is no fixed limit, sometimes the prostate regrows fast and requires re-intervention, and sometimes it's done in stages. The more times TURP is repeated, the higher the chance of complications. Personally, the doctor has done it twice at most on the same patient.
CT scan is more accessible in our setup than MRI. Is there any place for CT to confirm prostate cancer?▼
CT scan cannot be used to confirm prostate cancer diagnosis, only MRI can do that. But if MRI isn't available, CT scan is very useful for staging: once a cancer diagnosis is confirmed by biopsy, CT can tell you if it has spread outside the prostate.
What is the goal when deciding whether to biopsy for prostate cancer?▼
Finding clinically significant cancer (aggressive disease likely to harm the patient) while avoiding unnecessary biopsy and treatment of clinically insignificant, indolent cancer.
When might biopsy not be the right choice at all?▼
For patients who are very old, very sick, or who don't want further major treatment, where the honest conversation is about the risks and benefits of not investigating further.
In This Series: Diagnosis and Management of Prostate Cancer
- 1.Diagnosis and Management of Prostate Cancer
- 2.Why Physical Examination Still Matters in Prostate Cancer
- 3.PSA Testing: Age-Adjusted Thresholds, Density and Velocity
- 4.Who Needs Earlier Prostate Cancer Screening
- 5.When to Biopsy: Balancing Missed Cancer Against Overtreatment
- 6.Biopsy Technique and Imaging: Transrectal vs Transperineal, CT vs MRI
- 7.Managing BPH: From Lifestyle to Alpha-Blockers to Surgery
- 8.TURP: How Often It Can Be Repeated, and the Real Tradeoff
- 9.After Prostate Surgery: Incontinence, Neobladder and Quality of Life
- 10.Nutrition and Multidisciplinary Care in Prostate Cancer